MileIntel
Analysis

WestJet vs. Porter: 'More Premium' Depends on the Seat You Buy

WestJet has the bigger front-cabin hardware. Porter's advantage is in the main cabin. Here is how to match the airline to your trip.

MileIntel3 min read · November 5, 2026
A Porter Airlines Embraer jet climbing into a clear blue sky
Photo by Elliott Stambler on Unsplash

The short answer

If "premium" means a lie-flat bed, only WestJet is in the running. Its Boeing 787-9 business class has fully lie-flat seats, direct aisle access, premium dining and lounge access on long-haul routes. Porter does not fly widebody aircraft or offer lie-flat seats, according to Simple Flying.

If "premium" means a better seat at the back of the plane, the comparison tips the other way. Simple Flying's overall verdict is that WestJet has the stronger high-end product, while Porter offers a more upscale everyday experience for the average passenger. For most domestic and transborder trips, you are choosing between two different narrowbody (single-aisle) experiences, not two business classes.

Economy: where Porter's edge is

Simple Flying reports that Porter's Embraer E195-E2 jets use a two-by-two layout with no middle seats. Every passenger gets complimentary beer and wine and free Wi-Fi. WestJet's Boeing 737 economy cabin uses a three-by-three layout, so middle seats remain, and food and drink are buy-on-board.

WestJet is upgrading part of its fleet. In an August 18, 2026 release, WestJet said it had finished refitting its remaining all-economy aircraft formerly flown by Swoop or Sunwing. Those aircraft now have upgraded Premium seating and an expanded Extended Comfort cabin. Premium, Extended Comfort and Economy on those aircraft have fast, free Wi-Fi presented by TELUS. WestJet said it would begin refurbishing its legacy narrowbody aircraft in September, with completion expected by the end of 2027 and about 14 Boeing 737-800s updated in 2026. It also said it had restored legroom on 737s that briefly flew with 180 seats; those aircraft now fly with 174 seats (WestJet).

Our inference: Until the refurbishment program finishes, which aircraft you are booked on may determine which WestJet amenities you get. The release does not mention changes to the three-by-three economy layout or to the buy-on-board policy that Simple Flying describes.

Front cabin: a bigger seat or a bigger bundle

The two airlines take different approaches at the front, as the table below shows.

WestJet Premium sits in the forward rows of WestJet's 737s. It has wider recliner seats in a two-by-two layout and 37 to 38 inches of pitch. PorterReserve uses the same seat frame as the rest of the E195-E2 cabin, but with 36 inches of pitch in the first four rows. It bundles meals, cocktails and airport and booking extras into the fare.

In Simple Flying's assessment, PorterReserve often gives comparable legroom and better soft-product perks on shorter domestic flights. On transcontinental flights longer than four hours, it says travellers who want a true recliner or a lie-flat bed will find WestJet's hardware more comfortable. Simple Flying also summarizes a September 2026 review by Frugal Flyer. That review criticized cold meals in cardboard packaging and standard seat padding, and concluded that PorterReserve is best understood as an upgraded, hassle-free way to fly economy.

If an airport lounge is part of what you are paying for, note that PorterReserve does not include access to third-party lounges.

Other tradeoffs

  • Punctuality: Simple Flying cites Cirium data putting Porter's on-time arrival rate at 71.9% and WestJet's at 73.6%. The article does not say what period this covers, so treat it as a rough indicator.
  • Toronto airports: Porter flies from both Toronto Pearson (YYZ) and Billy Bishop Toronto City Centre (YTZ). Check which airport is on your ticket.

Bottom line

Simple Flying suggests Porter's standard cabin or PorterReserve for two-to-three-hour hops, and WestJet's premium cabins for long-haul trips where seat width and a flat bed matter most. Our read: Decide based on where you will sit. In economy, Porter's no-middle-seat cabin is the clearer step up. At the front of a longer flight, WestJet's wider seats, and on long-haul its lie-flat beds, are the hardware advantage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Porter Airlines have lie-flat seats?

No. Porter does not fly widebody aircraft or offer lie-flat seats. WestJet's Boeing 787-9 business class has fully lie-flat seats with direct aisle access.

Is PorterReserve a business-class seat?

Not in the traditional sense. It uses the same two-by-two seat frame as the rest of the E195-E2 cabin, with 36 inches of pitch in the first four rows. The fare bundles meals, cocktails, priority airport services, two free checked bags and fee-free changes. It does not include third-party lounge access.

Does WestJet have free Wi-Fi?

WestJet says its refreshed aircraft have fast, free Wi-Fi presented by TELUS. Refurbishment of its legacy narrowbody aircraft is expected to be complete by the end of 2027.

The Mileage Run

Get articles like this in your inbox

The Mileage Run — one short email when something actually changes your travel math. No filler, no affiliate trash, no spam. Unsubscribe anytime.